Coronavirus muddies U.S. economic data as business
closures push down response rates
Send a link to a friend
[April 07, 2020] By
WASHINGTON (Reuters) - A near total closure
of U.S. businesses as authorities try to control the spread of the novel
coronavirus could make U.S. economic data unreliable in the coming
months and harder to get a clearer picture of the severity of the
recession caused by the virus.
Government agencies such as the Labor Department's Bureau of Labor
Statistics (BLS) and the Commerce Department's Census Bureau and the
Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA) compile data, including the closely
watched employment report, by collecting information from businesses and
households through in-person and telephone interviews.
Investors, policymakers and businesses rely on economic data to make
critical decisions. The coronavirus' impact on data collection was
already felt in March's employment report, with decreases in response
With at least 90% of Americans now under some form of a lockdown to curb
the spread of COVID-19, the respiratory illness caused by the
coronavirus, economists say data collection will be severely
"This won't necessarily bias the numbers stronger or weaker but it will
add considerable sampling error to those numbers," said Michael Feroli,
an economist at JPMorgan in New York.
"Given the inherently backward-looking nature of economic data, economic
policymaking is often compared to driving by looking in the rearview
mirror. In coming weeks that mirror will be exceptionally foggy but we
can be fairly certain that we are driving into a wall."
According the BLS, the response rate for the household survey, from
which the unemployment rate is calculated, had a 73 percent response
rate in March, down about 10 percentage points in recent months.
The survey of establishments from which nonfarm payrolls are derived had
a collection rate of 66 percent last month. That was about nine
percentage points lower than average. The BLS also said personal
interviews were suspended during the collection period for the safety of
interviewers and respondents.
This survey period was in mid-March, when only a handful of states had
implemented "stay-at-home" or "shelter-in-place" orders.
"The unique nature of the coronavirus downturn means that the economic
data will be less reliable than usual over the coming months," said
Andrew Hunter, a senior U.S. economist at Capital Economics in London.
"Businesses forced to close won't respond to the BLS' surveys, and those
that do will by definition be relatively less affected by the pandemic."
[to top of second column]
A paramedic wheels a patient into an emergency arrival area at
Elmhurst Hospital during the outbreak of the coronavirus disease
(COVID-19) in the Queens borough of New York City, New York, U.S.,
April 6, 2020. REUTERS/Eduardo Munoz
BLS Commissioner William Beach acknowledged the challenges on Friday, but said
in the case of March's employment report, they "still were able to obtain
estimates from our two surveys that met BLS standards for accuracy and
On Monday, the BLS said it planned to continue publishing economic data as
scheduled and that "impacts from COVID-19 on data collection will be discussed
in a box note in the affected news release." In addition to the employment
report, the BLS publishes the monthly reports for consumer, producer and import
prices, as well as quarterly data on productivity and employment costs.
Normally the BLS' birth-death model, which it uses to calculate the net number
of jobs from new business and closings, would address distortions anticipated
from data collection woes.
"But it is slow to adjust even during normal recessions," said Hunter. "The
unprecedented speed of the recent business closures means it probably won't
prevent the payrolls data from being biased upwards over the coming months."
With 10 million people filing for unemployment benefits in the last two weeks of
March and millions more expected to have submitted claims last week, economists
are expecting payrolls to sink by at least a record 20 million in April and the
jobless rate to top 10%.
The economy shed 701,000 in March. The unemployment rate shot up 0.9 percentage
point, the most since January 1975, to 4.4 percent in March. The BLS said it
would have risen to 5.4% were it not for a sampling error.
Some economists said they would be keeping an eye on the private ADP employment
report to get a better picture of the carnage in the labor market.
There was no immediate response from the BEA or Census Bureau. Economists say
their data collection will also be impacted by the coronavirus. BEA publishes
data including the quarterly gross domestic product report. Reports released by
Census include monthly retail sales and housing starts.
"It may be difficult for the BEA to capture the degree of weakness given the
reliance on surveys and historical interpolations," said Michelle Meyer, a U.S.
economist at Bank of America Securities. "During the last recession, it took
several releases with downward revisions before the depth of the downturn was
(Reporting By Lucia Mutikani; Editing by Chizu Nomiyama)
[© 2020 Thomson Reuters. All rights
Copyright 2020 Reuters. All rights reserved. This material may not be published,
broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Thompson Reuters is solely responsible for this content.