The price of progress in China: 'We traded our lives for
Send a link to a friend
[December 14, 2018]
By Sue-Lin Wong
SHENZHEN, China (Reuters) - For four years
at the turn of the century, Wang Zhaohong worked on a demolition crew in
Shenzhen, clearing the way for the once-tiny border village to become a
Now, emaciated and struggling for breath, the bedridden 50-year-old says
the work he did will end up killing him.
Without proper safety equipment, he and his colleagues from a remote
county in Hunan province inhaled so much construction dust during
Shenzhen's development boom that they contracted silicosis, a
Wang's case is acute. He expects to suffocate by Chinese New Year.
This month, China will celebrate the 40th anniversary of its "Reform and
Opening," the economic policy that transformed it into the world's
Even as hundreds of millions of people have left poverty, Wang and
others like him are reminders of the heavy human toll of China's
development, and authorities have sought to censor information and
About 6 million Chinese either suffer from or have already died from
pneumoconiosis, or dust-caused lung damage that includes silicosis,
according to estimates by Love Save Pneumoconiosis, a Beijing NGO that
advocates for workers suffering from the condition.
Hundreds of migrant workers from three counties in Hunan province,
including Wang, have been protesting for compensation from Shenzhen.
"We used to wear the same mask for 10 days before getting a new one,"
Wang said in his village in poor, rural Sangzhi county. "At the time our
boss would say to us 'if you use a new mask every single day, how will I
ever make any money?'"
The workers earned 5,000-6,000 yuan ($739-$870) each month, double or
triple what other migrant workers were paid at the time.
Almost no one signed contracts, which has made it nearly impossible for
them to seek adequate compensation. The Shenzhen government has offered
some workers payments dependant on the severity of their illness of up
to 220,000 yuan ($32,000), according to Gu Fuxiang, one of the worker
representatives. But he said it was not nearly enough.
Their prospects look grim in what has been a nearly decade-long fight.
Security forces attacked them during their most recent sit-in at
Shenzhen's city hall in early November, according to five workers who
"For both the local government here and the Shenzhen government,
maintaining stability is absolutely their first priority," said Gu, who
has less severe silicosis.
"We traded our lives for development," he said. "The government doesn't
care if we're sick, if we die."
A Shenzhen government spokesman referred questions to the police
department, social security department, health department and economic
The health department hung up on a call seeking comment; the economic
reform department declined to comment. The police and social security
departments did not respond to multiple calls.
The health crisis is not unique to China; advocacy groups in the United
States struggled for decades to win compensation for workers dying of
such "dust diseases."
But the pace of China's building boom has created an unprecedented
number of casualties in just 40 years.
No city in history has grown faster than Shenzhen, whose economic output
surpassed that of its next-door neighbor, Hong Kong, for the first time
Shenzhen expects to have the largest metro network in the world by 2030,
with 32 subway lines, according to the official China Daily newspaper.
Migrant workers laid the foundations for many of Shenzhen's best-known
sites, from the city's northern train station, which connects Shenzhen
to Hong Kong and Beijing, to the Ping An International Finance Tower,
the fourth-tallest building in the world.
Despite the megacity's success, workers have mostly had to take out
high-interest bank loans and borrow from family and friends to cover
medical costs, their children's school fees and other expenses.
To pay for his hospital visits, Wang borrowed 50,000 yuan from a rural
banking cooperative that is charging him 11.27 percent interest per
quarter, according to the loan document he showed Reuters.
[to top of second column]
Visitors look at an exhibit showing the former Chinese leader Deng
Xiaoping planting a tree at an exhibition marking the 40th
anniversary of China's reform and opening up at the Museum of
Contemporary Art and Planning Exhibition Centre in Shenzhen,
Guangdong province, China December 4, 2018. REUTERS/Thomas Suen
"The bank still gives us loans because our children co-sign. My son has agreed
to pay them back once I'm dead," he said as he rotated home-grown sweet potatoes
roasting over charcoal next to his bed.
The Shenzhen government paid Wang 130,000 yuan in 2009, when his illness was
diagnosed, but he says it hasn't been enough.
"In China, the problem isn't a lack of money. Shenzhen has an enormous social
insurance fund. The problem is ideology," said Pun Ngai, a sociology professor
at Hong Kong University, who has spent years following the workers' plight.
"The Shenzhen government doesn't think these workers are their responsibility
since they aren't Shenzhen residents," Pun said. "And the government is worried
if they submit to the workers' demands, people from other provinces will also
come seeking compensation."
The social insurance fund of Shenzhen, with an official population of 12.5
million, totaled more than 540 billion yuan at the end of 2017, according to
The workers told Reuters that Beijing has come down hard, threatening them and
anyone who comes into contact with them if they speak out.
Authorities in mid-November forbade all websites from reporting or publishing
stories related to the Hunan workers suffering from silicosis, according to the
China Digital Times, which tracks censorship in China.
Prominent state-owned newspapers and television stations covered their plight in
2009 but this year have been silent on the issue.
This censorship is consistent with an overall political tightening in China over
the past five years and comes amid a crackdown on student-worker protests that
started in southern China and spread around the country.
In August, about 50 students and other activists from around the country came to
Shenzhen to protest with factory workers about the poor conditions at a factory
owned by Jasic, a welding company.
"The case of the silicosis workers this year has become very, very sensitive
because the government is worried it will become connected to the Jasic case,"
The workers have made 11 trips to Shenzhen this year but say they are still
waiting for adequate compensation. They are asking for compensation of between
500,000 yuan and 1.1 million yuan, depending on the worker's condition, Gu said.
Less than 12 hours after Reuters arrived in Sangzhi county, the local police
began calling workers, ordering them to report to the local police station and
verify with whom they had met.
The Sangzhi county police declined to comment.
"The authorities really know how to frighten us; a lot of the workers are too
scared to have anything to do with foreign media right now," said Gu, adding
that Shenzhen government officials had told him both his phone and WeChat were
But Wang said he was more worried about the huge debt he was leaving to his
family, and repeatedly wondered aloud whether there was any point in telling his
"Our country has progressed so quickly over the past 40 years, farmers don't
necessarily have to farm anymore, it's really wonderful," he said wistfully,
breathing with the aid of tubes in his nose, as X-ray images of his stricken
lungs hung in the small window that looks out onto his neighbor's house.
"I wish I wasn't bedridden, then I could go out and explore all that is out
there," he said. "Instead, I'm going to die very soon."
(Reporting by Sue-Lin Wong; Additional reporting by the Shenzhen newsroom.
Editing by Gerry Doyle)
[© 2018 Thomson Reuters. All rights
Copyright 2018 Reuters. All rights reserved. This material may not be published,
broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Thompson Reuters is solely responsible for this content.