Disability-rights advocates sue Illinois over physician-assisted suicide
law
[June 19, 2026]
By Sean Reed | The Center Square
(The Center Square) – A law that is set to legalize physician-assisted
suicide in Illinois is being challenged by disability-rights advocates
and organizations in federal court in the Northern District of Illinois.
The law, signed by Gov. J.B. Pritzker last December, is set to go into
effect on Sept. 12, but disability rights advocates, which make up the
“End Assisted Suicide Coalition,” are seeking to prevent it.
Similar laws have been passed in 13 states across the country, with many
also being challenged in court.
Ernest Galvan, a lawyer representing the group in its lawsuit against
Pritzker, the Illinois Department of Health and its director, told The
Center Square the group is challenging the law for its lack of
compliance with the U.S. Constitution and Americans with Disabilities
Act.
“The problem with that under federal disability law and under Illinois
disability law is that it creates a two-track system, a separate and an
unequal system of medical and mental health care for persons with
disabilities,” Galvan said.
Theo Braddy, executive director for the National Council on Independent
Living – a plaintiff organization in the lawsuit – shared a different
argument against the law, focused on morality.
“People like myself become disabled and all of a sudden we don't have
those supports. And then someone says to us when we're depressed and
isolated that ‘we have a way out for you, which is medical assistance in
dying – or assisted suicide,’’ Braddy said. “ What makes you think that
that option would not be something that people will go for?”
Braddy continued by saying that he feels society often treats people
with disabilities as a burden who aren’t worth paying for, and contends
that other solutions exist to help people with disabilities nearing the
end of their life.
Galvan said there is a stark difference between physician-assisted
suicide and other approaches to addressing terminal illnesses, such as
palliative or hospice care – which attempt to relieve pain and other
symptoms to improve a patient’s quality of life.
[to top of second column]
|
“Advocates of these assisted suicide laws try to blur that
difference, saying ‘the pain medications you might get – the
morphine and the morphine analogs – may also cause you to die
earlier because of the way they suppress your bodily functions,’”
Galvan said. “But that is very different from giving you these.
[They’re] essentially the same kind of cocktails of barbiturates
that they use to execute people.”
A release from Pritzker’s office detailed that a patient can qualify
only if two doctors agree that they have a terminal illness, giving
them less than six months to live.
A patient must also have the mental faculties and understanding to
choose the assisted-suicide option, which they can only pick after
being informed of all other options, such as hospice and palliative
care.
Galvan still took issue with a lack of oversight in the matter.
The laws "prevent medical licensing boards and other medical
regulating bodies of the state from looking into where these laws
are being abused to end people's lives for reasons that even the
sponsors of the law would consider illegitimate, such as financial
distress, family pressure, depression, anxiety,” Galvan said.
Braddy said he doesn’t think lawmakers have acted with malicious
intent, but the law is discriminatory against people with
disabilities regardless.
Braddy also suggested the paths to treatment would be different
among disabled and non-disabled people.
He said an able-bodied person who goes to a medical professional
with suicidal intentions would immediately be given support and
treatment, whereas a doctor would consider assisted suicide as an
option for that same person if they had a disability.
Galvan said the plaintiffs will attempt to block the measure while
litigation plays out. Lawsuits in other states have been brought
over the past three years, though none have concluded in that time.
All contents © copyright 2026 Associated Press. All rights reserved |
