Shelly Klinger shares Middletown history at July's Logan County Genealogical Society meeting

[July 22, 2026]    

At the July Logan County Genealogical and Historical Society meeting, Shelly Klinger shared some little known Middletown history.

LCGHS program chair Marla Blair said Middletown used to be a more important town in the county, and the area, because there was so much going on there. With much of it “faded” and “gone away,” Blair said, we don’t think of Middletown having the history it does.

Klinger lived in Middletown from birth to age 18 then lived in various other places in Illinois for the next 40 years before moving back to help care for her aging mother. Klinger said people act like she was never gone.

As Klinger sorts through the many items in her mother’s house, and many storage units, she has found a variety of artifacts from Middletown.

Klinger brought some of the artifacts including newspaper clippings, a 1952 Lincoln Community High School yearbook and a book called Memories of Middletown Illinois.

Middletown used to have three churches and three bars. The Presbyterian Church in Middletown is still there. Established in 1835, it is the oldest Presbyterian church in Logan County. Klinger said, once a month, she and several others cook meals in the basement of the church to distribute to the elderly.

The church bought pews from another Presbyterian Church in Springfield that Abraham Lincoln and his family attended. When Klinger is at church, she wonders whether she is sitting in the same spot Lincoln sat in. She will even move down the pew a bit thinking it may be his old spot.

A few years ago, the Knapp Chestnut Becker Library in Middletown caught fire when a neighbor’s fire got out of control. The roof was destroyed. The top part of the library contained uniforms of people from Middletown who fought in different wars. Klinger said people came together and raised thousands of dollars to help repair the building. It has not yet reopened, but they hope to someday.

The library is the oldest brick building in Logan County. Klinger said, in the library, there were two drawers full of birth and death certificates dating all the way back to 1848. Causes of death noted on the certificates include childbirth, flu, cancer and being drug down the street by a horse. Klinger brought samples of her birth certificate and her older brother’s birth certificate to show how different they looked.

In 1860, Klinger said the first murder in Middletown occurred when John Renna shot and killed James Rockford.

Stagecoach Inn was originally in Middletown. Klinger said the inn was disassembled and moved about a mile and a half out of town. Later, the inn was moved back to Middletown piece by piece.

[to top of second column]

Abraham Lincoln reportedly stayed at the inn on his route between Peoria and Springfield when he travelled the circuit. Unfortunately, the books with his signature burned. Klinger said there is confirmation that Lincoln’s wife and children stayed there July 1847 and October 1848. She would love to know where the books are at confirming the information.

When items found in the inn were auctioned off, KIinger’s mom bought a tall wooden piano from Abraham Lincoln’s days there for one dollar. Klinger said the piano made a “thunk” sound and when they opened the lid. They found a coronet, accordion and one dollar bill inside. Klinger donated the piano back to the Stagecoach Inn in 1988 but is unsure where the piano is now.

The Stagecoach Inn building is now called Dunlap House. Klinger said people can make appointments to tour the house. People come all the way from Peoria to see it.

Middletown was established in 1832, so the town will have a bicentennial anniversary in six years. About 50 years ago, the town’s population was 650. Klinger said it is now just 316. In 1910, Middletown had a big upswing and the population grew to 751.

There has been some speculation that Middletown was being considered as the capital of Illinois, though Klinger does not have a true record of that.

The town is nine blocks long, six blocks wide and .24 square miles. Klinger said in the 1940s, 1950s and 1960s, there were brick buildings up everywhere in Middletown.

Over the years, Middletown has had a laundromat, restaurant, opera house, grocery store, feed store and candy store. Klinger recalls buying two pieces of hot dog shaped bubble gum at the candy store for a penny. The town had a ballroom that later became a roller rink and bowling alley.
Middletown had a jail at one point and iron bars from it were later on a window in the library. Unfortunately, these bars were thrown away after the fire at the library.

Biggs feed store had a soda machine. The sodas cost a nickel, and Klinger said it was a challenge to get the soda out. The floors were beautiful old wood and very dirty, but Klinger said she loved “the smell of history in there.”

Just a mile and a half outside of town, there was a coal mine. Klinger said there are now several sinkholes in Middletown. One is almost big enough a car could fit in it.

Upgrades planned for Middletown include the park getting new equipment and a new water treatment plant being built just outside of town.

The old grocery store is being rebuilt to use as a storage facility.

Though Klinger is not quite sure where Middletown got its name, it possibly comes from being in the middle of the state. Others note it is also halfway between Peoria and Springfield.

Events in Middletown

Many years ago, Senator Daniel Webster ended up in Middletown when his wagon wheel broke. While in town, Webster visited the school and then the grocery store. Klinger said it was a highlight for the kids.

When Klinger was growing up, she remembers being involved in many parades down the park square in town.

Middletown used to have car races twice a year for two weeks. People would come from around the state and several states away for the races.

The Vin Fiz flyer [which was piloted by Cal Rogers and intended to be the first American transcontinental flight] made an unplanned landing in Middletown years ago. Klinger said people were excited to see the plane.

Klinger recalls attending Royal Neighbors of America meetings with her mom and still has a gavel with the name on it. There would be 30 or 40 women at these meetings. Klinger said Royal Neighbors of America started as more of a social club, then many became involved in the suffrage movement. Later, it focused more on offering life insurance. Chapters of the Royal Neighbors of America also help with special projects in communities.

With the bicentennial coming up in 2032, Klinger is hoping Middletown has a special celebration to commemorate the anniversary. She would like to see the town have a parade and perhaps even a carnival.

The next Logan County Genealogical and Historical Society meeting will be Monday, September 21 at 6:30 in the LCGHS building on Chicago Street.

[Angela Reiners]

 

Back to top