Lincoln Heritage Museum hosts presentation of Peoria abolitionist Lucy Pettengill

[October 14, 2025]    

The Lincoln Heritage Museum hosted an historical interpretation of abolitionist Lucy Pettengill on October 9 as part of their Journey to Freedom series sponsored by the Looking for Lincoln Coalition. Pettengill was portrayed by Laura F. Keyes, a librarian and historic voices presenter and lecturer from Illinois. Keyes portrays nine different women and presents lectures on a variety of subjects related to various aspects of American history. On Thursday night, Keyes brought to life Peoria abolitionist Lucy Pettengill in her Fighter for Freedom presentation.

Keyes addressed the audience as if all were participating in a ladies sewing circle operating as a cover for a clandestine abolitionist meeting on March 22, 1857. Keyes wore period clothing of a grey-striped hoop skirt and matching bodice, a bonnet of white lace and black ribbon, and a black and white cameo at her throat. She began her presentation to the “sewing circle” by reminding them of the Dred Scott Supreme Court case in which Scott sued his slaveowner for his and his wife’s freedom but lost his case due to laws that stated enslaved people were not citizens and therefore did not have constitutional rights, nor the right to sue. Keyes as Pettengill entreated her audience, “To stand up against these unjust laws!”

She read from a period newspaper and reminded the audience how the Missouri Compromise which limited the spread of slavery, was ruled unconstitutional, how Elijah Lovejoy, a minister, journalist, and abolitionist, was killed by a mob in Alton, Illinois defending the printing press upon which he published an anti-slavery newspaper, as well as the number of abolitionists in Quincy, Jacksonville, and other Illinois towns who had faced threats and harassment for their views and activities. “How do we live in a time in which we are worried about free speech?” she asked.

Keyes as Pettengill then explained how Pettengill had come from New York to Peoria in 1834 when it was still called Fort Clark and consisted of 30 cabins and a few frame houses. She came to Illinois with her husband, Moses, first traveling on a canal boat, then a steamer, then a brig to Chicago. There they joined other families traveling to Peoria by covered wagon with the men riding horseback and ladies and children in the wagons. They arrived in June and rented a room until they bought a cabin, then eventually built a business and a house. Pettengill taught Sabbath School in the old courthouse. With other residents, they organized the first Presbyterian church, which was the first church established in Peoria.


 

[to top of second column]

Laura F. Keyes portrays Lucy Pettengill. Photo by Stephanie Hall

In 1837, the Illinois Assembly adopted a resolution to condemn abolition societies. That same year Elijah Lovejoy was killed. In 1842, Pettengill’s church hired the Reverend William Allen, an abolitionist, as the pastor of the Presbyterian church. The next year, in 1843, a pro-slavery meeting accused Allen of disturbing the peace. A mob approached the church with ill intent where an anti-slavery meeting was being held despite constitutional laws protecting free speech and freedom of assembly. This is the year that the abolitionist focus moved to political action, however the only active for the cause were women because it had become dangerous for the men. Women could meet for "sewing circles” and the like without suspicion. The women of Peoria then formed a Female Anti-Slavery Society and after a state convention coordinating the local societies, a school was opened in Galesburg for black students

The Fugitive Slave Law of 1850 meant slave owners and bounty hunters could pursue escaped slaves into free states making it even more dangerous to journey north out of slavery and to support the abolitionist cause. Pettengill and her husband were part of the Underground Railroad guiding those seeking freedom to safety and providing for their needs along the way. Pettengill housed the people seeking freedom, allowing them to sleep by the stove during the day, feeding them, and directing them to the next safe house. She explained to the audience that the signal was a tap at the window followed by whispering “a friend.” She encouraged “the sewing circle” to provide filling food or portable food, clothing, and information and directions to safe houses in Galesburg or Farmington. She advised the group to keep crepe veils, long gloves, and bonnets on hand to disguise day travel. She told the group not to let the maid work at your home the day a fugitive comes. She instructed the group not to write anything down, to stay calm, and make measured decisions. Slave catchers do not watch women, she said, so they may work quietly and unnoticed.

At the conclusion of the presentation, Keyes fielded questions from the audience and posed for photographs. Lincoln Heritage Museum Director Ron Keller invited the audience to explore the Journey to Freedom exhibit displayed in a room adjacent to the museum. To learn more about Historic Voices by Laura Keyes, visit https://www.laurafkeyes.com/. To learn more about the Lincoln Heritage Museum, visit https://museum.lincolncollege.edu/.

[Stephanie Hall]

Back to top