True Crime at Mt. Pulaski Public Library
Guests hear about an 1882 triple murder in rural Mt. Pulaski

[November 21, 2026] 

Adam White of the American Dread podcast presented his research on several central Illinois crimes to community members at Mount Pulaski Library. Tuesday night, the discussion focused on murders that had happened just outside of Mt. Pulaski in 1882.

White has been and is still collecting details and stories regarding the murders of Charles McMahon, Robert Matheny, and John Carlock in August of 1882. He highlighted the difficulty in collecting information about a crime that took place 144 years ago because there was very little documentation of evidence. From the information he collected, he found that Charles McMahon was a farmer of means. He owned land and worked it with his hired hands, Robert Matheny and John Carlock. Carlock was the youngest of the men and was still attending school while also helping on the farm.

The farmhouse was tucked behind other farm buildings and tall brush. The three men were found with their throats cut and severe head trauma. The house was also turned upside down, as if the murderers were searching for something, and quilts were covering the windows.
 

[to top of second column]

After they were found, several suspects emerged. Local farmers organized searches for anyone in the area as they noticed that the horses on the farm were still being cared for. The local newspapers warned of the potential for lynching if the murderer was captured.

Eventually, John H. Hall was found guilty of the murders and sentenced to prison. It was reported that David Long served as an informant to detectives and was able to link Hall to the murder of McMahon. White expressed interest in filling in the gaps in the story and asked the crowd to share any information that might have been passed down to them through family stories or historical documents. One audience member shared that her husband was familiar with the story and believed McMahon had just sold hogs at market; therefore, he would have had cash on hand. She was also familiar with the location of the farmstead. Mr. White also added that there is a monument honoring the three men at Laenna Cemetery near Chestnut.

White also discussed one of the cases that he is currently working on in depth. This case is from Decatur. He shared several details that shocked the audience, and they began to engage, asking him questions and offering feedback. White’s podcast “American Dread” posts new episodes every other Wednesday.

[Joli Boerma Crane]
 

Back to top